Using Technology to Deepen Democracy, Using Democracy to Ensure Technology Benefits Us All

Saturday, April 11, 2009

A Fresh Argument

"Thomas," who accused me of being a Vitalist in an earlier turn of my waltz with the false, now accuses me of being a Vitalist:
From all this crap I only see, that Dale is a kind of vitalist.

He has no fresh arguments for his cause.

From all this crap I only see that Singularitarians are reductionists. They have no fresh arguments for their cause.

I'm not positing any kind of mysterious supernatural force in the way that the vitalists did. I'm pointing out that for so-called materialists you sure have an odd way of discounting the non-negligible material incarnation of actually-existing intelligences (on the basis of which alone you can have formed the notion of an emulable intelligence in the first place, given that they are the only actual game in town), and an odd way of discounting many dimensions associated with the actual exhibition of intelligence in the world (which include more than just cognitive reckoning with consequences but also sensitivity, imagination, empathy, emotionality, expressivity, savvy, instinct, improvisation, and a conscience that cannot be reduced only to calculation).

You can discount this objection as woo-woo mysticism if you like, but it looks to me like pointing out errors, one materialist to another. I daresay that dead-enders in the always only endlessly failed predictive powerhouse of the Strong Program might wonder what they keep on missing all these years to account for the interminable flummoxing of their certainties.

It's hard to resist the overwhelming sense that at least some Robot Cultists are willing so to substitute a vision of mere amplified calculation for actual intelligence because that reduction enables them to tell a more plausible story that would connect current technoscientific knowledge with the technodevelopmental accomplishment of the outcomes with which they identify so fervently as a community: Namely, first, the arrival of the superintelligent post-biological Robot God who either is Friendly enough to solve all their problems or Unfriendly enough to end the world altogether, as well as, second, the arrival of a "mind-uploading technique" through which their mortal vulnerable error-prone bodily selves can "migrate" into an imperishable digitality in which superintelligence, superlongevity, and superabundance is finally theirs.

Needless to say, whatever the actual sensible programming and science onto which they are glomming in crafting these formulations, this discourse is not itself a scientific one at all, but a discourse connecting selective experience to moral, aesthetic, and political hopes and calling upon older mythic archetypes and theological discourses. This is why it is sometimes handy to have a rhetorician in the house, amidst the breezing buzzing confusions of fixated coders.

UPDATE: "Roko" jumps in, responding to "Thomas's" attribution to me of "vitalism," suggesting instead:
He seems to be using the word “intelligence” in non-standard way.

But I'm simply using it in a way that captures the way you use it and experience it in your actual life. There is more to intelligence than reckoning with consequences.

Hereupon "Roko" soldiers on, hoping craftily to corner me into the reductionist cul-de-sac in spite of myself, apparently:
you concede that the human mind is a planner-reasoner-problem-solver-speaker-learner,

Among other things.
albeit a more effective one than any currently existing computer program in most domains

"Effectiveness" isn't all intelligence is up to. It also is up to "meaningfulness." And some of the ways in which it finds its way to "effectiveness" connect up to the ways in which it finds its way to "meaningfulness."

Whatever Wikipedia says at the moment on the subject, however fervently you might deny the salience or substance of the dimensions of intelligence to which I refer, I can no more deny them myself than I could deny the pressure that deforms the surface of my fingertips and the slick contact with surface that meets each strike of the keyboard out of which this reply is forming on the screen before my eyes right here, right now.
and that the property of being a planner-reasoner-problem-solver-speaker-learner is a purely algorithmic property which is substrate independent

I don’t think we know that at all yet, and I very much doubt it in any case. Setting aside abstruse philosophical quandaries I might have with such an effort at abstraction and reduction, let's turn instead to considerations I suspect you'll take more seriously (that isn't a compliment): To what extent was the substance of what is entailed at least in part by what you mean by “planner” “problem solver” and so on incarnated in the squishy organismic brain through evolutionary processes having to do with vicissitudes in the environmental idiosyncrasies threatening the survival or enabling the flourishing of the organisms to which we are indebted for the intelligent brains we actually now have? Intelligence isn't math, it's a squishy sloppy-wet mess, like a kiss.

That aside, I definitely won’t have you reduce the word “reasoner” to number crunching (however "pure" in your revealing terms). Reason is a far more capacious word in my book. For heaven’s sake, humanity is the Aristotelian rational, that is also to say, political animal!

Singularitarian Stick-To-It-Iveness Will Get the Robot Cultists to Robo-Heaven By Brute Force If Necessary!

Under the heading, "Those who can, create, those who can’t, criticize," a new interlocutor, calling themselves "DevNull" enters the scene to throw some darts at the effete elitist who dares perturb the precincts of hard he-man sooper-science with his muzzy emotionalist relativizing rhetoric:

To me Dale seems to say: There is none now, therefore there shall never be any. That’s no argument.


Angels, demons, fairies, genies, ghosts, golems, perpetual motion machines, immortality elixirs, love potions, squares circled.

It’s difficult yes, but not impossible. Even super super super difficult doesn’t mean impossible. What Einstein did was not super super super difficult but actually impossible to most people. But not to him.

Oh, look. Another Robot Cultist who fancies himself the next Einstein and the Wright Brothers all rolled into one.

Unfortunately for our singularitarian superlative futurologists, their terms are not “difficult” or even “super difficult” -- this isn’t a problem of having a “can-do” attitude —- the terms are actually deeply confused in a way that prvokes deep and dangerous confusions.

The actually-existing intelligence from which the Robot Cultists have superficially formed the idea of engineering its like is actually non-negligibly materialized in organismic brains and also socialized in the substance of its exhibition and far more multidimensional in its ways and means than are accommodated in the facile formulations Singularitarians accept as representing its “accomplishment.”

The Robot Cultists can’t achieve it on their terms because in achieving what they are actually seeking they would discover they confronted something altogether otherwise than an intelligence deserving of the term, because they don’t understand what they are even looking for in flabbergastingly basic ways. This is not, by the way, a "prediction" of the future, this is not a competing "prophetic utterance" and "The Future," this is an effort to expose an error in a superlative futurological discourse.
What’s clearly impossible to Dale (as it seems), may be rather obvious to some super super super smart scientist. I’ve existed in a world where technologies I now use daily didn’t exist. And tomorrow, I shall exist in a world where new technologies exist. One of them might be AGI. It’s just a machine (like us) with capabilities we call “intelligence”. Intelligence is the most powerful force in the universe. So what? Big deal.

You’re right, "DevNull." Just a little bit 'o stick-to-it-iveness and you’ll have that perpetual motion machine licked! Who cares what some whiny pomo Berzerkeley humanities types say. Accentuate the positive, sooper-scientists, you’ll get that circle squared, pull yourselves up by the bootstraps, extreme to max, dood!

Thursday, April 09, 2009

Understanding Superlative Futurology

"Superlativity" as I use the term very specifically in my critique isn't a synonym for "really big epochal technodevelopmental changes." Like most technoscientifically literate people, I expect those, too, assuming we don't destroy ourselves any time soon instead with our waste or with our weapons. Instead, Superlativity in my sense of the term names the effort to reductively redefine emancipation in primarily instrumental terms and then expansively reorient the project of that emancipation to the pursuit of personal "transcendence" through hyperbolic misconstruals of technoscientific possibility.

This personal transcendence is typically conceived in terms that evoke the customary omni-predicates of theology, transfiguring them into super-predicates that the futurological faithful personally identify with, but proselytize in the form of "predictions" of imaginary technodevelopmental outcomes. Nevertheless, superlativity in my view is a literary genre more than a research program. It relies for its force and intelligibility on the citation of other, specifically theological/ wish-fulfillment/ transcendentalizing discourses, more than it does on proper technoscience when all is said and done. It is a way of framing a constellation of descriptions mistaken for facts, and embedding them into a narrative that solicits personal identification, which then forms the basis for moralizing forms of sub(cult)ural advocacy.

The three super-predicates, recall, are superintelligence, superlongevity, and superabundance, and they correlate to the three theological omni-predicates -- omniscience, omnipotence, and omnibenevolence. But like the avowed articles of faith of the omni-predicates with which they are correlated, these super-predicates are ultimately incapable of functioning as factual assertions at all, they are self-consuming quasi-factual placeholders for the brute assertion of faith itself. Indeed, superlative aspirations are conceptually confused to the point of illegibility, and their advocacy amounts to what is essentially a faith-based initiative.

Neither culture nor subcultures deliver deification -- technoscience will never purchase omni-predication, omnipotence, omniscience, omnibenevolence -- and never will some robotic deployment of superlative technique deliver the secularized analogues to the damaging daydream of a deity the Robot Cultists are indulging in, superintelligence, superlongevity, and the circumvention via superabundance of the impasse of stakeholder politics in a world shared with a diversity of peers.

All culture is prosthetic, and all prostheses are culture. Technoscience is simply the collective prosthetic elaboration of agency. And agency, in turn, is our effort to achieve and maintain social legibility, accomplish ends, testify to and make sense of our lives, peer to peer, in a diverse abiding material discursive world that both enables and frustrates us in this. Freedom is our word for that collective experience. Freedom cannot properly be reduced to capacitation, the muscular amplification that is instrumentality, any more than it is properly fancied as an accomplishment of solitary sufficiency: our encumbrance is a condition of our collective elaboration of freedom, peer to peer, and what we want of our technique and what we make of it is likewise conditioned fundamentally by its play in an absolutely unpredictable interminable interdependent diversity of peers and their works.

There is no "overcoming" to be had of these limits, however many present limits and customs we overturn, inasmuch as finitude as such is literally the constitutive condition of the very experience of freedom we cherish. The superlative futurologists would idiotically obliterate freedom in their clumsy wrongheaded infantile wish-fulfillment fantasy of a toypile so high it reaches Heaven, of an endlessly amplified instrumental power that transcends freedom and delivers superlative variations on an omnipredicated godhead.

Each of the super-predicates of superlative discourse amounts to a personal investment in a stealthy article of faith proffered up as endlessly-deferred scientific "predictions." Confronted with such superlative utterances it is entirely beside the point to indulge in what appear to be "technical" disputes about the validity of the scientific claims that are hyperbolized into rationales for superlative articles of faith or to debate technodevelopmental timelines for superlative "outcomes." To indulge superlative futurologists in these preferred arguments is as little scientific as debating the number of angels who can dance on a pin-head with a monk or pouring over Nostradamus with some disasterbatory enthusiast to "determine" the exact date the world will end.

The phenomenological payoff for the True Believer, so long as these conversations play out in real time, is to confer onto their imaginary object of faith a substantial reality that the object itself cannot otherwise attain. It is better for everyone not to indulge this sort of irrationality at all, and certainly not to confuse this sort of thing with actual science or actual policy discourse to the cost of the indispensable work these enterprises actually do. Or, at any rate, one should understand this sort of thing as an essentially idiosyncratic aesthetic or moral matter on the part of its enthusiasts and treat it (even celebrate it as one always can appreciate kooky marginal fandoms) as one would comparable enthusiasms in their proper precinct.

Robot Cultists Decry My Pseudo-Science

"Thomas" sums up my skepticism on the Robot God priesthood and would-be Mind-Upload Immortalists in a word: "Vitalism."

Vitalism? Really?

It's like you want to pretend that noticing the actually salient facts connected to the materialization of consciousness in brains is tantamount to believing in phlogiston in this day and age.

I am a materialist in matters of mind and that means, among other things, that I don't discount the logical possibility that something enough akin to intelligence to deserve the description might be materialized on a different substrate. But logical possibility gives us no reasons to find ponies where there aren't any, and there is nothing in computer science or in actual computers on offer to justify analogies between them and intelligence, consciousness, and so on. That's all just bad poetry and media sensationalism and futurological salesmanship.

When Robot Cultists start fulminating about smarter-than-human-AI the first thing I notice is that they tend to have reduced human intelligence to something like a glandular calculator before going on thereupon to glorify calculators into imminent Robot Gods. I disapprove of both the reductionist impoverishment of human intelligence on which this vision depends as well as the faith-based unqualified deranging handwaving idealizations and hyperbolizations that follow thereafter.

The implications of the embodied materialization of human intelligence is even more devastating to superlative futurological wish-fulfillment fantasies of techno-immortalization via "uploading" into the cyberspatial sprawl, inasmuch as the metaphor of "migration" (yes, that's all it is, a metaphor) from brain-embodied mind to digital-materialized mind is by no means a sure thing if we accept, as materialists would seem to do, that the actual materialization is non-negligible after all.

UPDATE: Of course, "Roko" jumped right into the fray at this point.

In response to this comment of mine from the above -- “I don’t discount the logical possibility that something enough akin to intelligence to deserve the description might be materialized on a different substrate” --

Roko pants: "So let me get this straight: you think it is possible to build a computer that would deserve the name “intelligent”. From this I presume that you think it is possible to build a computer that is intelligent and smarter than any human -- as in, it can do any mental task as well as any human can, and it can do certain mental tasks that humans cannot do. Am I correct here?"

Of course, I said nothing about building a computer. You all can see that, right? You're all right here literally reading the same words Roko did. They're all right here in front of us. I get it that this is all Roko cares about since he thinks he gets to find his pony if only computers get treated as people. But computers are actually-existing things in the world, and they aren’t smart and they aren’t showing any signs of getting smart. Roko is hearing what he wants to hear here. Both in my response, but apparently also from his desktop (you don't understand, Jerry, he loves me, he loves me).

It should go without saying, but being a materialist about mind doesn’t give me or you or Roko permission to pretend to find a pony where there isn’t one. I can’t have the conversation Roko seems to want to have about whether he is “correct” or incorrect" to draw his conclusion from what I have said since all that has happened as far as I can see is that he has leaped off the deep end into spastic handwaving about computers being intelligent and smarter and acting this or that way, just because I pointed out that I don’t attribute mind to some mysterious supernatural force.

Despite all that, I also think, sensibly enough, that the words “smart” “intelligent” and “act” can’t be used literally to describe mechanical behavior, that these are only metaphors when so applied, and indeed metaphors that clearly seem utterly to have bewitched and derailed Roko (and his “community,” as he puts it) to the cost of sense.

I mean, who knows what beasts or aliens or what have you we might come upon who might be intelligent or not, however differently incarnated or materialized? But when we are talking about code and computers and intelligence we are talking about furniture that actually exist, and to attribute the traits we associate with intelligence with the things we call computers or the behaviors of software is to play fast and loose with language in ways that suggest either confusion or deception or both as far as I can see.

Is Superlativity Worthy of Consideration?

Upgraded and adapted from the Moot, brave "Anonymous," opines:
You're right Dale, few will listen to you about superlativity, now or ever.

Well, it's a philosophical critique and only a minority of people engage in such philosophical critique. By the way, this isn't an elitist condemnation of the majority -- people can be thoughtful without being philosophical, strictly speaking, after all.
Meaning, few will start saying "yes Dale, you're right, transhumanist discourse is wrong or silly or harmful." To the contrary, a lot of serious, bright, and thoughtful people will likely continue to see transhumanist discourse as having value no matter how many times you repeat your critique.

Ah, poor little Robot Cultist. Nearly everybody who comes into contact with the transhumanists decides they are silly and wrong and dismisses them on the spot as kooks, and quite rightly so. No doubt some people will continue to be drawn to superlativity, for reasons like the ones I mention at the end of the post to which brave "Anonymous" is responding: namely, "in order to sell their scam[s] or cope with their fear of death and contingency or indulge their social or bodily alienation or lose themselves in wish-fulfillment fantasies inspired by science fiction or try to gain some sense of purchase, however delusive, on their precarious inhabitation of a dangerously unstable corporate-militarized world[.]"

Only a vanishingly small minority of people are transhumanist-identified or avowed singularitarians and so on. Thoughtfulness is not exactly the quality these people share in my view.

Most people don't take the superlative futurologists and Robot Cultists seriously enough in the first place to understand why I devote the time I do to critiquing them. I don't think many grasp that superlative futurology is a symptom and clarifying extreme expression of corporate-militarist developmental discourse more generally, and that such futurology, in turn, is the quintessential ideological expression of neoliberalism.

I do think it is regrettable that I have not managed to attract more attention from like-minded critics of corporate-militarism, but I must say that not convincing a few dumb boys who fetishize their toys to give up their Robot Cult is hardly any kind of abiding regret of mine where the superlativity critique is concerned.

Tuesday, April 07, 2009

The Robot Cultists Have All the Facts on Their Side


"Roko" serves up the usual premature dismissal:
If you have a fact-based argument as to why smarter than human AI is not possible then please tell me.

Just what assumptions and frames are embedded in your notion of "smarter" here, and are the implications of those assumptions matters of fact? Are differences arising from these assumptions open to adjudication on the basis of what you consider to be facts?

People who have trouble distinguishing science fiction from science should be less cocksure that they always have the facts on their side, and that their skeptics are always ignorant or irrational.

Is "smartness" a matter of instrumental or formulaic calculation, are sensitivity, imagination, improvisation, criticism, expressivity dimensions contained in your notion of "smarter than human AI"?

Does it matter or not to your visions of post-biological smartness that intelligence has always only been materialized in brains, does it matter that performances of intelligence are always social, and that in some construals collaboration is already a form of greater-than-personal intelligence?

If not, why not? At what point is the trait you claim to be so palpably possible sufficiently remote from the actual phenomena denoted by the term "intelligence" that you might properly be compelled (by the demands of sense, I mean) to find some other word for what you are talking about?

What are the stakes of your attribution of "possibility" to the "arrival" of this smartness, whatever you happen to mean by it? Is it logical possibility? Is it theoretical possibility, however well-substantiated or not, however remote or not? Is it proximate practical possibility capable of attracting investment capital or demanding immediate regulation?

Do these distinctions figure at all in your determination of whether or not this question of engineering "smarter than human AI" is worthy of serious consideration?

If not, why not? Wouldn't these sorts of distinctions figure in most practical considerations of the kind you seem to think you are engaging in?

If you want to sell what looks to me like a faith-based initiative concerning the arrival of post-biological "superintelligence" you'll discover that skeptics you want to persuade don't have to meet your terms, you have to meet ours. It's the extraordinary claim that demands the extraordinary substantiation.

Your personal challenge to me is finally irrelevant, of course, since the challenge of scientific consensus is the one that confronts your claim and so far you have failed to attract that consensus. You may be able to find a cul-de-sac in which your claim passes muster for a marginal minority (that's the whole point of joining a Robot Cult, presumably), and you are surely able to best me or at any rate bamboozle me in some exchange on some technical matter I have neither the training nor the temperament to address the proper significance of, but all that is neither here nor there.

I pose my own challenges to you on the terms I am fit for, and those terms are relevant even if they are not the only relevant ones in a question like this, and even if you choose to demote them as not "fact based" and hence, apparently, unworthy of consideration. You'll discover that you live in a world with sufficiently many people in it who differ with you on the question of which concerns are the ones worthy of consideration that dismissals only ensure that you are dismissed. That, too, after all, is a fact.

Monday, April 06, 2009

Drextech As Superlative, Now With "Existence Proofs"!

Insofar as all of this recent drextech talk hereabouts is connecting up specifically with my Superlativity critique, it is important to note that where "nanotechnology" is concerned I tend to focus on claims that technodevelopment will arrive at a superabundance through which we will presumably circumvent the impasse of stakeholder politics in a world shared by an ineradicable diversity of peers. The aspect that I focus on is the discourse of superabundance as an anti-political wish-fulfillment fantasy.

This "anti-political" discourse, as it happens, tends to function concretely in the service of elitist-incumbent-authoritarian political ends, whatever the professed politics of its adherents.

But like the other super-predicates of superlative discourse, superabundance amounts to a personal investment in a stealthy article of faith proffered up as endlessly-deferred scientific "predictions." The three super-predicates, recall, are superintelligence, superlongevity, and superabundance, and they correlate to the three theological omni-predicates -- omniscience, omnipotence, and omnibenevolence. But like the avowed articles of faith of the omni-predicates with which they are correlated, these super-predicates are ultimately incapable of functioning as factual assertions at all, they are self-consuming quasi-factual placeholders for the brute assertion of faith itself.

Confronted with superlative utterances it is entirely beside the point to indulge in what appear to be technical disputes about the validity of the scientific claims that are hyperbolized into rationales for superlative articles of faith or to debate technodevelopmental timelines for superlative "outcomes." To indulge superlative futurologists in these preferred arguments is as little scientific as debating the number of angels who can dance on a pin-head with a monk or pouring over Nostradamus with some disasterbatory enthusiast to "determine" the exact date the world will end. The phenomenological payoff for the True Believer, so long as these conversations play out in real time, is to confer onto their imaginary object of faith a substantial reality that the object itself cannot otherwise attain. It is better for everyone not to indulge this sort of irrationality at all, certainly not to confuse this sort of thing with actual science or actual policy discourse to the cost of the indispensable work these enterprises actually do, or, at any rate, one should understand this sort of thing as an essentially idiosyncratic aesthetic or moral matter on the part of its enthusiasts and treat it (even celebrate it) as one would comparable enthusiasms in their proper precinct.

Anyway, to the extent that the drextech business takes up the faith-based discourse of superabundance it is susceptible to the superlativity critique, but while drextech is exemplary of Superlativity in this way, it is far from essential to it. It seems to me that late-century digital-utopianism and hype about immersive virtualies, as well as quite a lot of mid-century automation discourse also indulged conspicuously in superlative discourse as the anti-political gesture of an aspiration toward the technodevelopmental "accomplishment" of superabundance. I regard Roland Barthes' reading of "Plastic" in his Mythologies as yet another example of the same.

I think all this is related to but not exactly the same sort of thing that I was talking about when last week I discussed the relation of marginal ideas and warranted consensus in the scientific mode of reasonable belief ascription, and similarly related to but not exactly the same thing Richard Jones is pointing to when he delineates the ways in which the claims arising out of drextech fandoms are marginal to consensus science, are overconfident and uncaveated in ways that are uncharacteristic of consensus science, and rely on deeply questionable uninterrogated assumptions that would trouble most consensus scientists, and so on. He's far more qualified to address technical questions at a level of detail my own different training not to mention different temperament ill-suits me for, but I am qualified to know to stick to consensus where I am not qualified to falsify or substantiate candidate assertions for scientific belief and to recognize marginality by the available criteria on hand and treat it accordingly. It seems to me that my modesty is better suited to proper scientificity than the immodesty of the superlative "champions of science" who would deride my muzzy-headed lie-brul elite fashionable nonsensicality.

It does seem to me there is a common tendency in superlative discourse for its adherents to hang their hats on "existence proofs" the generality of which is scarcely substantial enough to bear the weight of confidence in particular outcomes and particular technodevelopmental trajectories that tend to get connected to them.

It is hard to see how biological realities actually substantiate the confidence drextechians seem to have in the technodevelopmental accomplishment of highly-controlled programmable general-purpose self-replicating room-temperature molecular manufacturing when that actually isn't what we find in biology after all. Similarly, it is hard to see how the realities of organismic intelligence actually substantiate the confidence AI-enthusiasts have in the technodevelopmental accomplishment of differently materialized intelligences, let alone bear the weight of confidence "uploaders" have that consciousness can migrate across substrates without loss.

One hears techno-immortalists declaring that because intelligence is material rather than supernatural this means that presently biological intelligence can migrate into imperishable digital networks in principle, when it seems at least as likely that the materiality of consciousness renders the concrete materiality of its incarnation non-negligible and hence less susceptible to "migrations." Indeed, I expect that the "plausibility" of such scenarios of migration (the frame itself is a metaphorical sleight of hand, after all, rather than any kind of lab result) derives more from the deep seated familiarity of mystical framings of insubstantial ensouled consciousness "imprisoned" by the material body more than anything else, however vociferously these superlative futurologists disdain religious faith otherwise.

In a nutshell, I think superlative faith-based initiatives find comfort in these "existence proofs" because they need to find them there, not because there is any reasonable support to be found in them. Skeptics are quite familiar with the faithful who find "proof" of God, and so of the immortality of their souls, in the sublimity of a buzzing blooming sun-drenched natural world without God or immortal souls anywhere on hand. It is a mercy at any rate that the faithful don't try to sell us on the notion that it is in such moments of inspired free-association that they are behaving as model scientists, which is what the galling flabbergasting spectacle of Superlativity too often seems to amount to.

There can be an appealing poetry in esoteric mysticism and in the aesthetic practices of personal perfection in which the faithful indulge -- so long as they don't become hectoring and puritanical I find it as easy to sympathize with their lifeways as I do other creative people, poets, punks, perverts, party-animals and so on. If the superlative futurologists just realized that they are another sf fandom and stopped messing with urgently needed public technodevelopmental deliberation in a time of disruptive technoscientific change, they could be perfectly charming and harmless as well, as better befits their preoccupations.

But to the extent that superlative discourse fancies itself a world-historical movement, whomping up a sub(cult)ural constituency, advocating an ideology from the vantage of an organizational archipelago impacting actual public discourse and actual policy, then I'm afraid it becomes crucial to identify its essentially faithful constitution and critique its mobilization and ramification in the world as such.

That Superlativity is not properly scientific is important to grasp and expose, especially given the tendency of superlatives to sell themselves as a kind of scientific avant-garde, but it matters more to understand not just that Superlativity fails to pass muster as scientific but that it is essentially a faith-based initiative indulging in moralizing politics from a sub(cult)ural vantage and hence constitutes a threat to secular democratic multiculture in much the same ways that perniciously politicized fundamentalist faiths always are.

Wherein I Am Ripped to Pieces

From an exchange with a person called "Roko" (their comments are italicized):

It seems that Dale’s primary argument is a factual one not an axiological one: he is arguing that all this technology stuff is hyperbolae, that it ain’t gonna happen.

My primary argument is that superlative aspirations are conceptually confused to the point of illegibility, and that their advocacy amounts to a faith-based initiative. One would expect in consequence that, despite their protestations to the contrary that they are consummate scientists, superlative futurists would have little empirical evidence to show of being taken seriously by actual scientists (citations in scholarly journals, singularitarians, techno-immortalists, and nano-cornucopiasts in a competing diversity of academic labs with real grants, and so on). And precisely this is the case.

Marginality matters where one wants to claim the mantle of consensus science for one’s advocacy, as it does not necessarily matter where one wants to defend, say, the validity of an unpopular aesthetic judgment or political position.

Such an argument needs to be prosecuted in a more rigorous way than Dale is capable of.

This is laugh out loud funny to me. My whole point is that you people don’t even grasp the genre of argument you are making, let alone the criteria of warrant properly associated with it. You don’t grasp that your perpetual motion machines and square the circle pamphlets don’t constitute science at all in their essential claims (that is to say the claims that are their unique contribution, as against the scientific and policy claims they nibble at the edges of, the claims nobody needs to join a Robot Cult to make contact with). Superlative claims seem to me to be essentially theological, aesthetic, and moral(istic), and those are the terms in which I seek to understand them and critique them.

I challenge Dale to post to Less Wrong an argument whose conclusion is that the probability of smarter than human AI within the next 100 years is less than 0.1%. He will be ripped to pieces.

I challenge you all to stop writing checks you can’t cash and just go burrow off to your secret genius labs in the asteroid belt and code your superintelligent postbiological Robot God or your drextechian genie in a bottle or your sooper immortal cyborg shell, whereupon I’ll genuflect to your quasi-deified super-predicated post-self all the livelong day in the most edifying fashion imaginable, if you like. The same goes to fundamentalists who can gloat from their perches on heavenly clouds as I roast after death in some hell-nook for my atheism or the gay thing or whatever.

Richard Jones Is Talking Sense

Buried deep in the Moot still unspooling from a post last week is this rather bolstering comment from Richard Jones which deserves to be disinterred:
Sorry to come to this late, but since my name has been mentioned maybe it's still worth my clarifying a few things. My engagement with enthusiasts for Drexlerian nanotech began somewhere around 2003-4. I'd begun developing the critique which took shape in my book Soft Machines (which is in essence an refutation of arguments from biology to justify Drexlerian, "Nanosystems" style nanotechnology, of the kind that Martin cites above) in the late 90's, with a couple of low profile publications. As this engagement went on, at a technical level, I became more and more puzzled by some odd features of the spokesmen for Drexler -- the strength of their will to believe in the face of sceptical arguments from mainstream nanoscience, the fact that belief in "Drextech" didn't come alone, but that it formed part of what an anthropologist might call a "belief package", together with a strong conviction that radical life extension would soon be possible, that we'd soon have superhuman artificial intelligence, and that this would lead to a "singularity". It also struck me as odd, in a time when nanoscience was truly global, that these people seemed to have a background that was rather culturally, ideologically and geographically specific. In this context I found Dale's analysis and critique extremely helpful and revealing. As I've written before, I've grown to realise that the technical issues that I'm qualified to write about aren't really at the heart of this business, and that Dale's perspective from rhetoric and cultural studies is really valuable.

On the matter of tone, there's certainly a difference in personal style in the way Dale and I conduct our critiques. I don't choose to express myself the way Dale does; but this doesn't mean I don't enjoy his writing or think he's not correct in many essentials. My natural tone tends to (sometimes ironic) detachment, but this also doesn't mean I don't sometimes envy Dale for his passion and engagement.


Over at Michael Anissimov's Blog, another varation on this conversation has been ongoing. To my repeated charges that superlative claims amount to faith-based initiatives, and altogether fail to pass muster as scientific (all the while Robot Cults sputter about what incomparable indispensable champions of science they are, battling menacing effete relativists in the humanities like yours truly), Michael dismissively replied, from his planet:
Many scientists are becoming convinced that this stuff [the technodevelopmental "accomplishment" of superintelligence, superlongevity, superabundance] is a big deal.

To this I responded, roughly (I've expanded and clarified my point a bit now that I'm on my own real estate, follow the link for the exact words):
I regard this utterance as the most flabbergasting imaginable nonsense. “Many” as compared to how overabundantly many who don’t?

Do you want to get into citation indexes, Michael? To the extent that citations are mounting a bit (they had nowhere to go but up, after all), how many citations outside a small circle that keep citing each other do these citers garner themselves? How often do these citations occur outside the in-group as throwaways in intros and conclusions — connected to statements roughly to the effect of, “some nutters go so far as to say superlative blah blah utility fog blah blah mind uploading, cite Moravek, cite Kurzweil, etc, whereas in this paper I stick to rather more conventional assumptions and modest expectations?" That is to say, how often do these citations amount to little more than logrolling among superlative futurologists themselves or function as extremities against which more mainstream scientists and policymakers situate themselves as more mainstream?

The whole point of the archipelago of Robot Cult think tanks like IEET and ImmInst and Singularity U and WTA (er, I mean, Humanity Plus!) as far as I can see is to cough up a hairball of apparent respectability for these superlative formulations for media outlets to hook onto, to help your membership organizations get more bottoms into the pews and more eyeballs onto the webpages, what you call “getting out the message,” very much in the way neocons whomp up faux respectability for their scams via Heritage and AEI.

Richard Jones appeared in the midst of that conversation as well, with this enormously helpful comment:
I can perhaps amplify Dale’s comments above. The paper “A Design for a Primitive Nanofactory” [this paper was cited by Michael as evidence that superlativity was not as marginal as I claim it to be] was published in a transhumanist journal which is not indexed by the major scientific databases. According to “Web of Science”, which tracks citations in the mainstream science journals that are in its database, the paper has been cited three times since 2003, by two papers authored by Phoenix himself and another by Drexler and Allis.

Plenty of mainstream scientists are excited by the many possibilities that our increasing control of matter on the nanoscale open up, many of them are developing increasingly sophisticated nanoscale machines and devices. But very few of them, in my experience, give any credence to the superlative claims of “nanofactories” and “superabundance”. “Superlative discourse”, as Dale calls it, pollutes the discussions we should be having about the many potential or possible impacts of developing technoscience; instead talking, as AnneC says, in terms of Utter Certainty about particular (ideologically favoured) outcomes on well-defined timescales that to mainstream science seem fantastic.

Sunday, March 29, 2009

Far Out

Upgraded and adapted from the Moot: Far out ideas are crucial of course to the progress of science, and rightly cherished as such, but they don't actually count as warranted science until they manage to attract an actual consensus.

If scientific consensus finds some technoscientific claim unwarranted chances are that it is just that, unwarranted, even if it is true that some such views eventually do achieve consensus and so contribute to scientific progress. (Hi, there, would-be singularitarians, techno-immortalist uploaders, sooper-longevity pill-poppers, holodek dreamers, eugenicist schemers, drextech cornucopiasts, nice to see all your fresh-scrubbed froth-mouthed faces again!)

Futurological subcultures not scientific, they are better conceived as fandoms, communities of shared enthusiasm that identify with idealized outcomes or with would-be gurus (or sometimes even figures who themselves might otherwise pass muster as proper scientists or scholars or experts however marginal some of their notions might be) and substitute insular echo-chambers, passionate tribal devotions, and uncritical True Belief for the actual substantiation, experimentation, falsification, publication that yields scientific consensus.

In the really extreme modalities of futurological sub(cult)ure I criticize most emphatically here, like the eugenic transhumanists, the techno-immortalists, the singularitarian Robot God priesthood, the nano-cornupiasts, and so on, I fear that these tendencies are particularly pronounced, too often caught up in, at best deeply vulnerable to, the cul-de-sac of outright cultishness and all its unfortunate authoritarian paraphernalia.

Saturday, March 28, 2009

Futurological Immaterialism and Neoliberal Immaterialism

The literally fraudulent financialization of the US Economy under neoliberalism is completely off the rails, of course, and the critics are railing at last and en masse, still too little and possibly too late, but years and years and years after the wheels started coming off for all to see it seems that some are connecting at least some of the dots constituted by the breadcrumb trail of rapid episodic irrational exuberances of market-bubbles-and-looting-sprees consummating the Eyeblink Empire of postwar "Washington Consensus" corporate-militarism.

There are still more dots that remain for us to connect, if you ask me.

I would point out, for one, that the so-called "acceleration of acceleration of change" that corporate-militarist futurologists and especially Robot Cultists so love to hyperventilate about (and actually this "accelerationalism" is a mainstream corporatist trope, but the so-called Singularitarians are its reductio ad absurdum) derives its plausibility as a notion from our shared experience of the instability of this neoliberal financialization. Indeed, apart from a few technical vicissitudes incomparably more modest than their hype ever remotely justified, the so-called "acceleration of acceleration" really amounts to nothing but that instability of neoliberal financialization only simply as that instability is experienced by the relative beneficiaries of that financialization, or those who at any rate identify with those beneficiaries.

More dots.

The singularitarian nerd-rapture chorus line who have crowed loudest but not alone about this technoscientific "acceleration" toward digital transcendence, that is to say the ones who fulminated about a kind of historical "progress" but one without the materiality of actual social struggle in it, are usually the very same futurologists and techno-utopians who crow about an "intelligence" coded in software that is always imminent but never arrives, one without the materiality of brains or sociality to incarnate or substantiate it. They are often the very same futurologists and techno-utopians who pine for the enhanced "experience" of a "virtual reality" without the materiality of friction or chance or sublimity or entropy to substantiate it. They are often the very same futurologists and techno-utopians who pine for an immortal life "lived" somehow without life but as immaterial information in the cyberspatial sprawl or in invulnerable robotic shells, life as an endless prolongation of static senseless death-in-life where nothing can matter lest in mattering it "kill" the dead-alive "immortal" machine.

In the concluding chapter of my dissertation, Markets Without Materiality I discuss a futurological work by market fundamentalist David Friedman (son of the shock doctrine market fundamentalist guru Milton Friedman) in which he enthuses about the desirability or even necessity of a retreat into virtual reality as a means to escape the dilemmas posed by surveillance technologies according to another libertarian thinker, David Brin. I am compelled in that conclusion to note
the curiosity of the spectacle Friedman’s argument is making of itself here…. Robert Heilbroner has famously described economists as “the worldly philosophers,” as collaborators in the most relentlessly materialist humanist tradition on offer. And [yet] here, to preserve the norms and assumptions of political economy an heir to that tradition, one who has described as his chief contribution to it simply that he takes some of that tradition’s commonplace assertions to “their natural conclusions,” finds that he must denigrate the very material and bodily foundations on the basis of which that tradition has always defined itself and distinguished itself from all others. To retain what he takes to be a political economist’s conception of worldliness, a political economist finds he must disdain the world.
Life is lived in material bodies, intelligence is incarnated in material brains, material situations, material dynamisms, peer-to-peer, social struggles play out in material histories materially circumscribed by finite ecosystems, mortal lives, error-prone efforts.

To deny or renounce these materialities in flights of fantasy, whether in fundamentalist religiosity or market fundamentalism or techno-utopian True Belief, is always to be supremely foolish to say the least and usually testifies to an infantile dread and denialism of our ineradicable and actually constitutive finitude, contingency, vulnerability, a dread and denialism that, whenever it is permitted to guide our affairs, leads always only to waste, deception, aggression, disaster.

Here in the consummation and bankruptcy and ruins (and not for the first time) of market ideology, we are reminded (and not for the first time) that the pace at which the tidal forces of "supply and demand" and the "education via unprofitability of ignorance or error" and the "rationalization via capital flight of panics and bubbles" and comparable "market mechanisms" manage to compensate for disruptive events and bad information is too different from the pace at which metabolism is maintained in human bodies and life is lived in human history for these mechanisms to sustain those lives and that history in a human way, however wholesome they may be in their own inhuman term.

Meanwhile, the assumption of infinite growth without which "market orders" could not be mobilized toward their indefinite ends in the first place is altogether too perilous to the actually-existing limits of ecosystems to sustain the planetary biosphere on which we all ultimately depend for our survival let alone flourishing. The life of that dead abstraction the market (a very different thing from the heterogeneous marketplaces in which people have gathered to trade goods and stories in their definitely different ways throughout history) is not curtailed by the end of your life, its mechanical pulse is not diminished in the cessation of your living pulse, its digital time is unfolding at a pace aloof from your life-time, its blind indifferent voracious ends are no more your ends than would be a glacier's, it is indifferent to the differences that are your all.

Since I borrowed the title of this blog from Hannah Arendt's motto, "for the love of the world," it will come as no surprise that my preoccupation with futurological discourse and Robot Cult nonsense more generally derives from my strong sense that these discourses arise from and express a profound hostility to and alienation from the world that must be loved in its material mattering, a material mattering very much including its materially situated materially inter-personal political substance, if it is to last and not be lost to us.

In this the futurologists are very much of a piece with (though some perhaps dupes of) more mainstream discourses of corporate-militarism, which likewise disdain the materiality of their suffering peers and of their creative peers, of true production and of true prosperity, of historical struggle and the actual experience of freedom in the world.

To love "the future" on whatever construal is in my view above all to disdain the present, or more particularly it is to disavow that futurity that is materially present in the present, in that diversity of peers whose palpable presence bespeaks the openness in the present to change for the better in acting in concert (in both collaboration and in contestation) with our peers who share the world.

We are not robots, progress is not a robot, history is not a robot, intelligence is not a robot, your brain is not a robot, experience is not a robot, peace is not a robot, creation is not a robot, production is not a robot, prosperity is not a robot, justice is not a robot, the environment is not a robot, life is not a robot.

There are differences that make a difference in the human world, differences that matter in human history, and to attest to a robotic indifference to these differences is not to exhibit prophetic insight or superior strength but to side with death out of idiotic greed or panic in the most brainless way imaginable.

Futurology is the quintessential discourse of this debased epoch of corporate-militarism. Let us leave "the futures" to the traders in futures, the robots to the robotic, and the rackets to the racketeers. There is still time to reconnect to the futurity available in the presence of our peers we call freedom, and in freedom build something better in the world. Fuck the futurologists and the financiers and the fraudsters.

Thursday, March 26, 2009

Science Not Sales

Upgraded and adapted from the Moot:

In my recent post Science, Politics, and Administration, I wrote, among other things:
Those who prefer to emphasize scientific outliers as definitive rather than simply indispensable to science over the stolid solid science of consensus tend to be crackpots or dupes who foolishly mistake themselves for champions of science or who are indulging in rank fraud.
To this, an "Anonymous" commenter replied (this is much abridged, do follow the link for the whole exchange):
In my view, this isn't the best way to spot crackpottery. Oh, yes, crackpots always channel Einstein, Wright brothers, Tesla, Von Braun, etc. ad nauseum. But, unlike the genuine articles, they want special treatment of some kind for their ideas. Always…. [The] Wright brothers built their "flier" (and half a dozen various flying prototypes) first, and then sought investors. Some imitate those examples faithfully, and whether their ideas make it or fail miserably, I respect them. But do crackpots, con men and their dupes do that? Never! They don't bet their lives and fortunes on their ideas, they want a sure thing. So they go to courts, to TV, to gullible venture capitalists, to the internet, organize their own diploma mills, and get their share of "degrees", "fame" and sometimes, alas, quite real money. Their "success" is of course, as fake as their ideas and methods, even financial one…. The sheer hypocrisy of this fake-dissent is enough to make those types absolutely intolerable. Any dissenters are welcome, except fakes.
These points are well taken, surely, but I don't happen to doubt that at least some pseudo-scientific crackpots and futurological fraudsters are indeed willing to struggle selflessly and even die (at least professionally) for their dumb ideas, or might at any rate be too stupid or caught up in a full froth of True Belief to grasp that these are the stakes in the game they are playing at.

What matters to me is that we insist on the distinction of marginal hypotheses that are indispensable in principle despite their marginality to the process by means of which we arrive at ever more capacious consensus technoscience over the long run, and actual scientific consensus worthy of the name and warranting our reasonable belief as such many of the present pillars of which began as marginal notions but no longer are so.

I think that most non-crackpots who are strong champions of presently marginal notions will concede that their views do not yet represent consensus science even if they rightly or wrongly expect them one day to achieve that distinction.

They best not compensate for their marginality by pretending to a certainty that nobody has, they best not handwave about the ignorance or irrationality of their detractors rather than seek to better substantiate their cases the better to persuade them, they will surely be aware and best welcome the custom that it is the extraordinary claim that demands extraordinary evidences and that their marginality puts the onus on them, they will best reasonably qualify their claims in the face of objections rather than hyperbolize and make to bulldoze them over, they best behave like scientists rather than salesmen (or futurologists, all of whom are salesmen).

Slavoj Zizek Is a Blogger

His books are not books in the customary sense. Rather, he is blogging lucratively onto pulp posts that are published as books once they accumulate sufficient weight to tip the scales of gatekeepers in the midst of the distress of their terminal crisis. And the standards and assumptions of that chimeric rhetorical mode, not quite journaling not quite journalism not quite meditation should bear on our evaluations of Zizek's productions of the last ten years or so. This is not a condemnation of Zizek so far as that goes -- tho' there are plenty of things he's blogged over the years that I have disapproved of, who cares -- but a vindication as much as anything, really, something to account for his idiosyncratic practice (the seat-of-the-pants tempo and repetitiveness and kinda sorta editedness of the writing, the ripped from the headlines topicality and copious citations of online sources in footnotes just itching to be clicked, the vertiginous juxtapositions of high and low culture -- a distinction he actually depends on for his writerly special effects, not one he is effacing in his writing) as well as to account better for my own continued enjoyment of his blog-post anthologies all these years despite feeling more than a little appalled by him most of the time.

More Geoengineering

Upgraded and adapted from the Moot. Jose Garcia wrote:
I don't think seeding the oceans with iron filings was ever a very respectable idea in the first place.

Still there is biochar which seems like a credible geoengineering strategy. And I think we're going to be forced to think about geoengineering at some stage because going zero carbon may not be enough.

Look. People need to start planting trees and region-appropriate home gardens, in addition to going zero carbon, regulating toxic materials and manufacturing processes to within an inch of their lives, and so on. Carbon isn't our only problem, given aquifer spoilage and soil erosion and the bursting of the bubble of the "miracle" of petrochemical input-intensive industrial agriculture. Inasmuch as biochar was already a pre-Columbian agricultural technique and most projects employing it today seem to be rather small scale, I am wondering whether "geoengineering" is really the right word to use to describe any effort at carbon-pollution remediation through local practice up-scaled (always only where region appropriate) via education, regulation, price incentivization, and so on.

I know enough about organic gardening to know that people who want to believe in technofixes consistently and even systematically underestimate the resilience of even devastated ecosystems that are finally being cared for rather than mistreated, and I suspect that at least some talk of tipping points being crossed that force us "reluctantly" to accept the necessity of geoengineering interventions and nuclear archipelagos and so on ultimately express the failure of imagination one has come to expect of corporate-militarists more than anything else.

I disagree strongly if you are implying that seeding the oceans with iron fillings was never treated as a respectable idea by those who think such things are respectable in the first place and megaphone them endlessly and so distract us from more local and distributed and scalable strategies that are known to be effective but are less likely to be profitable for incumbents.

Although I don't know enough about every other geoengineering strategy "on offer" to suavely trot out all the dangers and limits and hyperbole occasioned by each one (as neither unfortunately do the overabundant majority of those who handwave most enthusiastically about these strategies to the cost of sense) I do know that skipping from one scam to another to another as each is exposed as hype while the more difficult work of gathering reliable data, implementing piecemeal regulation and price incentivization, better design practices, general education, facilitation of organic, local, wholesome, carbon neutral practices at the proper scale and intensity can be done but likely won't be done while greedheads are endlessly jerking off to their effort-deferring guilt-denying profit-making authority-retaining fantasies of "greening" corporate-militarism via geoengineering isn't exactly the best idea.

Actually, as I have said before, I don't rule out geoengineering interventions in principle -- even though, as with most things futurological, many of these are entirely fantastic daydreams of megascale engineering that don't really connect up at the level of data or do-ability with the urgency of environmental problems at hand nor with accomplishments of more local strategies with track records of actual successes that could be effectively scaled via regulation, education, facilitation and so on.

My whole point is that I am skeptical about geoengineering, skeptical of those who prefer such interventions over others, skeptical of the hyperbolic discourse through which they are advocated, skeptical of their occasional genuflections to "reluctance" and "skepticism" that never has any impact on their actual advocacy.

I think it is not a co-incidence that corporate-militarism would shift from a very public denialism about environmental problems directly to a very public advocacy of geoengineering solutions to environmental problems.

The continuity between these two positions of incumbents maintaining control through extractive/industrial/capital-intensive/broadcast formations possibly matters more than the discontinuity between the two of first denying and then admitting the existence and scale and seriousness of environmental problems.

This isn't to attribute any bad motives to Jose at all, by the way, since he may well be as aware and concerned about the damage done by denialist discourse and futurological technofix-hype discourse as I am here, but just wants to ensure that the widest possible range of strategies remain on the table. I would agree with that enthusiastically.

The truth is that I expect the inherent drama of geoengineering interventions together with their likely comparative profitability to incumbents will ensure that these interventions will always draw more than their share of serious attention and consideration, whether they warrant it or not, and so we needn't worry so much about their neglect as about their preferential treatment despite the scale and intensity of their impacts in ill-understood environmental systems on which we depend for our lives.

Saturday, March 21, 2009

Futurological Blah Blah

Upgraded and adapted from the Moot: A couple of days ago I posted a little survey of a few very recent or soon to be voted on administrative and legislative decisions that represent promising puzzle-pieces in an emerging story of a slow liberalization of the failed policies of the generation-long racist puritanical War on (some) Drugs.

The failed policies are real, the people they have failed are real, the liberalizations are real, the struggles, the education, the agitation, the organizing underlying the liberalization are real.

In the Moot, "Mike" -- who warns me that he "may be too transhumanist/technophilic for your liking" -- offers the following comment:
I suspect in the next 10 to 20 years we will see a lot of progress in this area. New neurotechnologies like deep TMS and ultrasonic neuromodulation may allow non-invasive targeting of reward related regions of the brain. This could conceivably lead to cures for many addictions. So drugs may merely become superfluous and unnecessary.

By the way, "Mike" also says some nice complimentary things about Amor Mundi, whatever our disagreements which, it goes without saying, is appreciated, but I am skipping over to the actual substance of his comment which, as he feared, is not at all to my liking. And, again as he suspected would be the case, it is his "transhumanism" and "technophilia" that is the problem.

Let me put it this way.

A meteor could hit the earth and "end" the problem of addiction for everybody on earth for good, too.

It really could.

But, to my mind, surely, it contributes less than little to the serious work of policy-making or activism that would facilitate more sensible and just outcomes where consensual (or not) private (or not) use and regulation of variously unhealthy (or not) variously addictive (or not) substances are concerned, however, to waste too much time pondering the whole meteor strike scenario.

Or, at any rate, it is almost always wrongheaded to file the time one spends thinking that way (which might, after all, be quite as edifying as the time one spends reading a good book or praying or masturbating, all of which have their places in the lives of those whose private perfections make recourse to them) under the heading of "serious thinking about actual problems that need thinking about" here and now.

With respect, here is what I hear "Mike" saying to me at the key point in his comment:

Blah blah futurology "may allow" more blah blah futurology hence "could conceivably lead to" still more blah blah futurology and "so" dramatically still more blah blah futurology.

As an exercise, imagine it is 10 to 20 years ago and Mike's counterpart (there were many, there always are) offered up some comparable futurological thought experiment that was also logically possible, I suppose, in the abstract, certainly enough to sell a story, this or that promising technique in a lab somewhere or idea of a technique he might have read about in OMNI magazine could, with a little luck and linearity appear on the scene and scramble the terrain and circumvent all the problems that presently define it. But either that idealized outcome didn't come to fruition at all, as these things almost never really do, after all, or let's say, something like a qualified variation of the idealized outcome did indeed "arrive" after a fashion, through the developmental glass darkly, through the inevitable complex socio- cultural- regulatory- promotional- engineering- economic- political- emotional- cluster-fuck of a trajectory that nobody could really sketch out back then, the ineradicable interminable stakeholder struggle that came to actually distribute the costs, risks, and benefits of its stepwise fraught fruition, in ways that articulated the substance of the outcome in ways that have little connection to the idealized outcome..

The futurological enthusiast talking then like "Mike" is talking now contributed less than little to the clarity or possibility or justice available in the vicissitudes of that struggle. Or, if he did contribute some such measure here or there, it was almost entirely accidentally so, accidentally in the same way that any poet or politician or well-placed prostitute could have done.

And worse than that -- in my view -- that futurological counterpart likely did a lot of abiding definitive damage instead, amidst the sparks of incidental insight, confusing idealized outcomes with real developmental struggles and sensible deliberation about actually-existing costs, risks, and benefits before us.

The fact is that the worst variations of futurological discourse (which I do not attribute to "Mike" explicitly, nor to most "transhumanist-identified" and "singularitarian" dupes of Robot Cultism, but they really should be made to better understand the company they are keeping) were media hype-notists and disasterbators whomping up irrationality to attract attention to themselves or salesmen whomping up exuberance to get at the money of their marks. We are reaping the whirlwind of corporate capitalism's smarmy smart guys and stooges right here right now.

Futurology is the hyperbolic quintessence of neoliberal discourse: Hyperbolizing derangements of sense in the service of elite or incumbent advantage, peddled as neutral cost-benefit analysis.

Foresight is all very well, indeed, it is indispensable, but when would-be developmental deliberation and planning assumes the tonalities of prophesy or salesmanship or substitutes abstract projection for proximate substance you can be sure that it is an explicit racket, more often than not, or, more innocently but quite as terrible, it is a confused and disavowed engagement with contemporary social and cultural problems displaced onto a symbolic terrain denominated as "the future."

Saturday, March 14, 2009

What's Wrong With "Transhumanism"?

This is my latest of countlessly many efforts to date to characterize succinctly my criticism of the so-called transhumanist "movement," "ideology," "program," whatever it is. This one was written in response to a press query. You would be surprised how often I get such questions, I think usually from would-be journalists or perhaps grad students sniffing around for some writing angle. As always happens in such efforts, this version of my critique emphasizes some things, de-emphasizes others, captures some things nicely pithily, misses other things entirely, but since I cannot know what if anything will come of it, I figured I'd post it here at any rate so that the minutes of effort it represents aren't wasted entirely. This time the questioner also wanted to know how "technoprogressivism" differed from "transhumanism," possibly fancying some juicy sectarian squabble between weird futurological gurus might be in play. If nothing else I hope I managed to disabuse him of that.
People mean different things by "transhumanism," both those who sympathize or even identify with it, and those who disapprove or even ridicule what goes on it its name. I use the term "transhumanism" myself to deploy critiques of a complex of overlapping techno-utopian technodevelopmental attitudes and programs, all of them anti-democratizing in their primary impact, in my view:

[1] Transhumanism arises out of a familiar strain of Enlightenment thinking that tends to a distortive mechanistic reductionism and un(der)critical technophilia, a strain that has met with criticisms since it first emerged both from Romantic (and other) critics of Enlightenment but also from different quarters within Enlightenment as well;

[2] It activates and exaggerates the familiar irrational passions of instrumental rationality (dread of impotence and lust for omnipotence in particular) especially in moments of disruptive change;

[3] It substitutes for the pragmatism of a secular democratic technodevelopmental vision of collaborative problem solving and consensual self-determination a more faithful "transcendental" vision aspiring after personal superlongevity, superintelligence, and superabundance -- this being a superficially "technicized" and hyper-individualized appropriation of omnipredicated Divinity, omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence -- a vision that is conceptually confused and usually terribly deranging of sensible technodevelopmental deliberation at the worst possible historical moment;

[4] It affirms a politics of biomedical "enhancement" that in valuing a parochial "perfectionism" over a consensual diversity of lifeways amounts to eugenicism;

[5] It endorses elite-technocratic circumventions of stakeholder deliberation in matters of technoscientific change (especially worrisome given the tendency to eugenicism), usually justified with the familiar anti-democratic alibi that "accelerating change" is ill-understood by everyday people affected by it (of course any characterization of technodevelopment as monolithically accelerating is patently false, and often, I think, is little more than a description of the catastrophic social instability provoked by neoliberal financialization of the global corporate-militarist economy as experienced by the relative beneficiaries of that instability, that is to say, by the mostly white, mostly male, mostly well-off, mostly well-educated, North Atlantic consumers who identify in the main as "transhumanists");

[6] It is relying ever more conspicuously on a discourse of existential risk (an analog to and exacerbation of reactionary "war-on-terror"-discourse) and geo-engineering response that conduces especially to the benefit of incumbency over democracy, the corporate-military-industrial-broadcast complex over emerging insurgent p2p-formations;

[7] It substitutes for the politics of democratizing social struggle amidst a diversity of stakeholders over new and actually-emerging technoscientific changes a dangerously inapt politics of sub(cult)ural identity, a movement politics mobilizing personal and shared-group identification with particular idealized (often incoherent) technodevelmental outcomes designated "the future," organized by dis-identification with actually existing planetary peers in their diversity;

[8] It is constituted in its organizational substance by an archipelago of inter-related so-called "think-tanks" and membership organizations supported by fandom subcultures, many of which are disturbingly indistinguishable from cults with all that this implies in the way of social alienation, manic PR and hyperbolizing rhetoric to attract attention rather than contribute to sense, criticisms misconstrued and attacked as defamation, and the whole banal bestiary of authoritarian hierarchy from True Believers to would-be gurus peddling pseudo-science.

These critiques are overlapping, but not seamlessly so, and one will find "transhumanist-identified" people who will represent better or worse targets for various combinations of these, as you will also find different levels of awareness and understanding among them about the entailments between these critiques.

It is true that for better or for worse I have personally become associated with the term "technoprogressive," but when I hear talk of "technoprogressive resistance to transhumanism" it seems especially important to me that you grasp that "technoprogressive" as far as I have ever been concerned is just a shorthand for the more gawky, awkward phrase "conventionally progressive, democratizing politics focused on questions of technoscientific change." It is not, properly so-called, some rival ideology to "transhumanism." Indeed, many "transhumanists" have appropriated the "technoprogressive" label themselves as a stealthy PR designation of some versions of the "transhumanist program" and so I can't say with confidence that the term is a proper placeholder for resistance to "transhumanist" silliness in any case.

I am personally interested in a potentially democratizing confluence of p2p-formations and an emerging planetary environmentalist politics as a way of overcoming the postwar impasse of corporate-militarist (neoliberal/neoconservative) Washington Consensus global hegemony. Also, I am interested (and, not to put too fine a point on it, enormously worried) about the planetary dissemination of non-normalizing genetic, prosthetic, and cognitive medicines in a world of precarious status/labor, fearing an anti-democratic imposition of experimental subjection in the service of elite "enhancement" rather than a progressive politics of informed, nonduressed consensual prosthetic self-determination. Surely what is wanted is an equitable sustainable consensual technoscientific planetary multiculture.

This perspective puts me at odds with so-called "transhumanists" most of the time, who either disapprove of this emphasis, or who have nothing to contribute to its accomplishment while at once offering up endless confusions that befuddle the proper work of democratizing technodevelopmental social struggle on which its progressive accomplishment entirely depends.

But I cannot pretend that my "technoprogressive" vantage (one among many that are possible) provides me a rival ideology, program, or subculture with which to confront organized "transhumanists" on their preferred terms. It doesn't.

Monday, March 09, 2009

Is Obama the Face of Ongoing p2p Democratization?

It is a commonplace to point out the ways in which the Obama Presidential campaign depended on p2p formations for much of its success. It is customary -- and quite correct -- to say that Obama depended on the extraordinary fundraising of millions of aggregated small donations as well as the circulation of images and excitement about his vast rallies to acquire and parlay the early momentum without which he would likely scarcely have seemed a viable candidate as compared to Clinton or Edwards according to Establishment media pundits and incumbent partisan figures and so on.

We can only wonder how many millions more were inspired by the words of Obama's "Yes We Can" speech through their contact with its transformation by will.i.am into the now iconic song and video that proliferated deliriously via YouTube and hundreds of thousands of large and small blogs like this one, rather than by their direct or broadcast contact with the original speech itself.

And it is also true that Obama's Presidential ethos took on the coloration of p2p in ways that spectacularly amplified its force, from his insistence that his campaign was not about him but about us all, that change is a collective and participatory process, that we are the change we are looking for, to his pragmatic insistence that Washington must be made more transparent, responsive, collaborative.

But it is also quite striking to observe the ways in which the Obama Administration continues to mobilize peer-to-peer formations to implement its agenda as well now that it is in power, especially given Obama's spectacular popularity as compared with the Congress that must partner with the Administration to materialize Obama's policy goals.

Take a look at this page from Obama's Organizing for America: Take the Pledge.

Notice that signing the pledge provokes a series of ever more specific solicitations of effort, weaves you ever more deeply into a distributed organizational effort to facilitate the Administration's agenda.

It's fairly breathtaking, actually, not only in its sophistication, but also -- at least as a possibility worth contemplating -- as a diversion of Netroots energy and intelligence directly into the Obama apparatus.

I signed the Pledge and would urge sympathetic readers to follow the link and sign as well, but I will admit that my excitement was tempered by a few questions.

Even if you agree with Obama's agenda, or at any rate agree that fighting for his agenda is the best way we can apply the lion's share of our energies right now the better to open up possibilities for even more radical changes that the center-left Obama himself might not approve (which is my own position), there are real questions about what it means for the Executive branch to take up and to some extent appropriate the forms and also the energies of Netroots agitation and organizing in this way.

Does this amount to a powerful democratization of the American Executive? Does this render the Executive more beholden and accountable to the people, more directly expressive of popular will? Does this threaten a domestication of the insurgent and critical force of p2p democratization? Is there a worry that we might be MovingOn from MoveOn, peer to peer, in ways we might later come to regret?

Consider the ways in which Organizing for America differs from Accountability Now, a conspicuously more familiar Netroots campaign, conjoining figures from Daily Kos, Firedoglake, OpenLeft, ColorOfChange, Blog PAC and MoveOn.org together with figures from Netroots congenial forces like SEIU and the United Steelworkers to recruit and support progressive leaders and candidates for primary challenges to those Democratic and other incumbents who fail to reflect the progressive aspirations of their constituencies.

To what extent are these two formations complementary and to what extent competitive? Do they represent different faces for ongoing p2p democratization (in the United States at any rate)?

For me these questions take us into deeper perplexities and provocations. Can partisan organization and actual governance be democratized via the internalization of p2p formations and thereby be rendered more essentially progressive in their work, or are professional campaign apparatuses and administrative functionaries an inherently conservative force in society with the consequence that proper p2p democratization should remain a kind of abiding external check on their susceptibility to rationalization, corruption, incumbency, inertia?

Notice that we might decide that these professional formations are indeed in some important measure inherently inertial and conservative and yet still view them as indispensable to the maintenance of legitimate rule of law and the accomplishment of social justice on which the scene of informed nonduressed consent depends for its legibility and force and on which, in turn, democracy itself depends.

The ongoing and emerging forces of p2p-democratization seem to me to exacerbate the paradoxical inter-dependence of disruptive progress, diverse democratic expressivity, and legitimate equitable governance on one another while at once they endlessly undermine and co-construct one another in various measures in their play in the ongoing social struggle of, by, and for peers in public of which democracy actually consists in its substance.

As I said, I did sign the pledge over at Organizing for America, and I do cheerfully urge my readers to do the same. And I am also excited by the Accountability Now project and suspect I'll be giving them money and drawing attention to their issues here and elsewhere. It remains to be seen just how and how easily these ramifications of the Netroots expression of p2p-democratization will reconcile in theory, however, for now at least, they are managing nicely enough, so far, in practice.

Monday, March 02, 2009

Wired Tired Mired Dired

The Down Jones closed at 6,763 today. I wonder if the superlative technocentrics and Robot Cultists will still declare with undimmed fervor that their Singularity Is Just Around the Corner? I do hope they aren't unlucky enough to live in any of the parts of the United States where it is snowing, since these days that inevitably means infrastructure failure here at the pinnacle of high-tech just this side of techno-transcension. Perhaps they can step off the Holodek, pop a superlongevity pill, drop in from the nanobotic utility fog interior of their perch on the L-5 torus, and take a flight on the Concorde over to explain to my impoverished intelligence and imagination why my strong skepticism (to put it politely) about the "inevitable future" of robotic techno-immortalization under the warm embrace of the superintelligent robot god is so obviously unfounded all the while clucking their tongues and rolling their eyes at my ignorance of science.

It pays to remember that at the same time the techno-utopian "digirati" were breathless with excitement about the Extropian transhumanists (No death! No taxes! Libertopia uber alles!) they were meanwhile witheringly dismissing as prescientific emotionalists and ignoramuses and negative nellies and "fashionably nonsensical" relativists and all the rest of that tired jazz anybody who questioned their "Long Boom" theology, their embrace of Enron and the rest of the Ponzi schemers of the "New Economy" or who asked on the basis of what exactly their "Dow 40g, Man!" checks were presumably being cashed.

Lest this post be misinterpreted as a depressive dirge denying the present its real chance for positive change, I want to point out that the futurological hype of the Robot Cultists is and has always been the furthest thing from actual hope or actual science or actual sense. The futurological congress has always been fueled in the main by a witch's brew of social alienation, deranging reductionism, loathing of bodily vulnerability, reactionary fears of historical contingency and of worldly lifeway variation, and no small exhibition of the authoritarian tastes either for giving orders or for taking them.

Right about now, a proliferation of peer-to-peer formations, collaborative citizen expressivity, problem-solving, criticism, agitation, and organizing, together with the transformational Obama Administration that peer-to-peer democratization has birthed and now facilitates and pushes on has unleashed a rising wave of reasonable workable progressive intelligence and imagination into this moment of history. No theology of transcensional new age singularity babble. No would-be priestly authorities or gurus claiming to dictate the "will" of History or Reason to acquiescent consumers. No, it is democracy that is taking up the real work of technodevelopmental social struggle to solve humanity's shared problems, to enable informed, nonduressed prosthetic self-determination (where "prosthetics" equally encompass what pass for medical therapies and what pass for "lifestyle" choices), driven by and accountable to ever more of the stakeholders to change, demanding ever more forcefully that the costs, risks, and benefits of change reflect the stakes of the diversity of peers with whom we are making the world we share. We are well rid of the self-appointed "smartest guys in the room," the boys-with-their-toys, the futurological fraudsters, the ponzi schemers, the wired digirati and superficial self-help salesmen and design gurus, the superlative ideologues with the Keys to History in their hands and dollar signs in their eyes.

Democracy doesn't need digirati, and moralizing fundamentalist movements, whether explicitly religious (as with American Christianists and comparable Talibanists with their attendant charismatic priests and warlords) or notionally secularized and technicized (as with superlative techno-utopians, market fundamentalists, and Robot Cultists with their attendant charismatic gurus and technocratic elites) have no abiding part in the force of ongoing planetary peer-to-peer democratization and consensual lifeway polyculture.

Sunday, March 01, 2009

Sasha, 1996-2009

My partner and I celebrated our seventh anniversary this month, but neither of us really approve of Hallmark Holidays and we didn't make a big deal out of it. I had papers to grade anyway, and Eric was doing work from the computer in his home office as well. I only mention it today because of another anniversary connected to the first that became sadly salient yesterday afternoon.

Eric and I moved into the little Rockridge bungalow where we still live today after we'd been together for a year, and that move was the occasion for a different unholy union (apart from our own, I mean). Each of us had chosen to care for a feral cat from the SFSPCA as a companion. Eric had chosen Sasha seven years before we met and by the time I entered the picture they were an incredibly tight-knit little family.

I say that Eric chose Sasha, but the story is that Sasha chose Eric, pretty much leaping into his arms unbidden with his motor running like mad the moment he set eyes on Eric, and this after exhibiting indifference to hostility to pretty much everybody else who had given him a glance up to that point. Sasha never veered from that assessment of Eric a day of his life. I have never seen such monomaniacal devotion from a cat in my life, it was incredibly sweet and a little bonkers.

I chose my own feral disaster area, Sarah, after Eric and I met. At that point I had been mourning the loss of my companion Rodent (the awful name has a dumb story attached to it that we can skip), who had been a kitten in the last litter of a family cat from childhood (Grasshopper, daughter of Cleo), and who had lived with me the whole decade I lived in Atlanta, lived with me there through well over a dozen moves and who knows how many friends and boyfriends and so on during the times of my adventuring, moving with my partner of the time Jules (still very good friends, he's living in Switzerland now) from Georgia to California when the time came for grad school at Berkeley. It's amazing what banisters our animals are as we climb the steep stairs.

Rodent died cuddled next to me while I slept Christmas Eve, 2001, in the big apartment overlooking Dolores Park in the City I rented at the time with two friends, both of whom were home for the holidays thus leaving me alone in that echoing warehouse of a place at the worst possible time. I always regretted very much that Eric never had the chance to meet Rodent, and I also regretted that Eric's Sasha -- who had a perfect, uncanny physical resemblance to my desperately missed Rodent -- wanted nothing to do with me at all.

As I said, Eric and Sasha were a pretty tight-knit unit of many years when I entered the scene. Eric's a rather solitary person, like I am, and Sasha was not at all used to intrusions. Early on, when I would come to Eric's place Sasha would leap to the top of his ratty, ragged, ill-smelling green-carpet tower and stare at me with unblinking fixity for hours with the most predatory stare imaginable. My territorial incursions were not appreciated. My alien smell was anathema. My efforts at cooing and friendly pats were impertinences beyond bearing.

When Eric and I found our bungalow for rent through a friend, the place was so charming, the street so sweet, the price so right we just made the leap, and it felt like one -- not only because we both have fairly cautious natures and hadn't been together for that long, really, but also because we simply couldn't imagine what it would be like to weave our two crazy-cat families into a crazy-quilt that wouldn't be in tatters within days.

Our Sarah is a plump owl-eyed girl with a Hitler mustache, but she is far from as intimidating as that sounds. She has a bird in her head where her brain should be, for one thing. Leaves tracked in from outside are well-matched antagonists for her ferocity. Her battle hisses and trills are so adorable, Eric and I sometimes try to provoke her to irritation just because she makes such a cute spectacle of herself when she is enraged. Like Sasha, she was plucked up by the SFSPCA from Golden Gate Park, her mother and brothers and sisters all dead, and she nearly the same. When I brought her home, Sarah still had a terrific gash in her neck from some bird of prey trying to make lunchmeat of her. For the first years of her life she was completely skittish and spastic. And Sasha, as I have said, was a grumpy, jealous, and obsessively territorial beast.

To put it plainly, Eric and I were scared to death to introduce them. It was possibly the most flabbergasting thing I ever saw when Sasha, upon meeting Sarah in our new home, confounded every expectation and scenario we had spun, and was instead instantly cowed into submission by our little girl, giving ground to her in everything she asked for days and days.

For Sasha, Sarah was some deus ex machina. For Sarah, Sasha was at most a mild amusement. I'm not entirely sure that she grasped the fact that we had moved into a new home at all, rather than simply moving through a locked door in the old place to a new wing. Sarah's extreme blank stupidity makes her the most unflappable and stoical creature within miles. When Eric and I were playing the game of choosing who would play each of us in the movie version of our lives, we chose for Sarah a bag of mixed dried beans.

Within a few weeks, Sasha had rectified the initial power imbalance between them, and had come to an accommodation with me (especially since Eric and I decided I would be the sole food-slave to get in his good graces). We sometimes had the feeling that however devoted the cats remained to us, they represented for one another the only real people in the house. We humans were pawns selectively deployed in elaborate politics we could scarcely understand. The territories they had staked out between them were palpably demarcated, mutually respected, but seemed to include contested zones for which they would skirmish through scent-marking rituals that they would impose on table and chair legs and on doorways and so on literally for hours and hours on end, patiently roving through the rooms, doing their grim work and undoing the work of the other, day after day. Sarah and Sasha were incredibly real for one another, and they were very contented in their surreal shared cat world. At night, after we had gone to bed, they would call to one another and you could hear them chasing each other downstairs, galloping on their cat-feet, playing like lunatics.

It really is a hard thing to try to convey what a sweet and charming cat Sasha was. He showed these aspects of himself to so few. With strangers he was standoffish at best, slinking off to hide under a bed when guests were here, and greeting them with what was almost inevitably called a "banshee howl" or "Nazgul shriek" once he grew impatient that they had lingered too long in his home. You may laugh, but words cannot convey the truly unearthly uncanny sound he could emit when he was unhappy. That jagged nails across a thousand chalkboards iceberg tearing into the steel of the Titanic deranged dinosaur menacing some distant lemur ancestor sound would make every hair on your body prick at its pore like an ice-cold electrocution.

Sasha scared everybody, animal, vegetable, mineral. Cat lovers were especially offended at Sasha's indifference to their earnest ministrations and aggression at their attendance -- it felt like a personal failing to be found wanting by Sasha, and everybody but Eric was found wanting. I am not exaggerating when I say that I personally felt less accomplished in the award of my Ph.D. (well, face it, having Arnold Schwarzenegger's signature on your diploma makes it feel a bit like a novelty item, like a whoopee cushion or something) than I did after a half decade of what psychologist Carl Rogers would call the offer of "unconditional positive regard" that Sasha grew to love me and let me in to the charmed circle of his care, second only to Eric. Those last couple of years Sasha would let me pick him up in my arms and would purr and nuzzle my nose and deign to let his forehead be kissed. These were scenes unavailable to the wider world, precious beyond description.

Like many feral cats, especially male ones, Sasha was plagued all his life through with medical problems, especially digestive issues. He was never an easy cat to care for. He had periodic crises, and then manic bouts of pure punk behavior in the recuperative aftermath. He had been eating less than usual for weeks and walking a bit stiffly lately. He was as bright eyed and spunky and affectionate as ever with us, and we would give his fur a rueful brush and joke that he was getting to be an old man.

While I was away teaching on Tuesday, a sudden crisis sent him in his kitty carrier to the pet hospital down the street. We spent an anxious couple of days playing phone tag and hearing that the good doctors were struggling to stabilize him enough in the first place to administer the tests to determine what was happening with him. Thursday I lectured on formal logic while the minute hand of the clock tapped toward the number which I knew would trigger Eric's call to determine whether or not Sasha should be put to sleep to end his pain and fear in some strange place among strangers.

I hadn't had a chance to say goodbye and had scarcely been able to focus on anything for days. Actually, the news seemed better than we expected and we were able to bring Sasha home with some antibiotics. Friday night he collapsed again. We were told he was suffering from pancreatitis. He spent a night sleeping with Eric all to himself in the guest room downstairs, to his utter delight. He had a last long day at the home he had loved for half his life, cozied up to his favorite heating grate behind the living room chair while we scratched his head for hours.

He was a terrible mess, though, unable to eat and stiff with pain, but just as sweet faced and bright brained as ever. The doctors declared him beyond healing and to be suffering in a way that would only get worse the longer it went on, and we put him to sleep in a blinding white room with an evil needle to a shaved patch of skin on his back leg. I held his soft little paw pad and rubbed his chin and he was sweet as an angel when he vanished from the world, his clear eyes wide and kind for me the whole time. I hope my finger on his chin smelled like home.

Nobody can know like Eric does, and like I do, what we have lost in losing Sasha, what we miss without our grumpy, sociopathic, sweet little punk man around anymore. This is dedicated to him.